ALL-STAR OF THE YEAR
[2002] Osyrus
[2003] Osyrus and Alias
[2004] 'Superstar' Vince Jacobs
[2005] Seymour Almasy
[2006] Lowell Dot Com
[2009] Max Danger and Alias
[2010] Keith Scott Zimmerman

HERO OF THE YEAR
[2002] SilverHAWK
[2003] Alias
[2004] Alias
[2005] Seymour Almasy
[2006] Seymour Almasy
[2009] Andy Sharp
[2010] Sheffield

VILLAIN OF THE YEAR
[2002] Osyrus
[2003] Vincent Pembridge
[2004] 'Superstar' Vince Jacobs
[2005] Khristain Keller
[2006] Lowell Dot Com
[2009] Max Danger & Iceman
[2010] Z

INNOVATOR OF THE YEAR
[2002] Osyrus
[2003] Jason Kain
[2004] Quinton May & God's Forgotten Son
[2005] Seymour Almasy
[2006] 'The Jackpot' Jimmy Cain & Lowell Dot Com
[2009] Brian Spaes
[2010] Omega

EVOLVER OF THE YEAR
[2002] ICU
[2003] Alias
[2004] Quinton May
[2005] Sars The Clown
[2006] Andy Sharp
[2009] Trevor Wilson
[2010] Jesse Ramey

NEWCOMERS OF THE YEAR
[2003] Jason Kain and Quinton May
[2004] Fejona Min and God's Forgotten Son
[2005] Kelly Flawless and 'The Jackpot' Jimmy Cain
[2006] Coral Avalon and 'Biohazard' Dean Matthews
[2009] Brian Spaes and Trevor Wilson
[2010] Ryan Billows and Tyson XL

GROUP OF THE YEAR
[2003] El Janitors
[2004] Splink
[2009] Heirs Of Wrestling
[2010] The Night Life

MOMENT OF THE YEAR
[2002] ACW RETURNS - SEPT 8th 2002 COURAGE
[2003] Best of Se7en, Match Seven, Sudden Death - KING OF AGES
[2004] SilverHAWK wins back the Ownership of ACW - RELENTLESS
[2005] Seymour Almasy FTW! - ENDGAME
[2006] Lord Lowell burns ACW to the ground - COURAGE 100
[2009] 'We are all ACW!' Speech - ACW's ONE-OFF SHOW
[2010] 'Z IS!' Z wins the World Title after a year of machinations - ENDGAME 2010

MATCH OF THE YEAR
[2002] Triple Cage Match - World Championship - SilverHAWK (c) vs Osyrus - BREAKOUT
[2003] Best of Se7en, Match Seven - World Championship - Jason Kain vs Alias - KING OF AGES
[2004] King of Ages Final - Ladder Match - GFS vs Quinton May - KING OF AGES
[2005] Television & Scorpion Title Match - Five-Way Elimination - ENDGAME 2005
[2006] Gimmick Hell - Lowell Dot Com vs Jimmy Cain vs Coral Avalon - LEGENDS II
[2009] Ultimate Submission Match - Max Danger vs Kelly Masters - LEGENDS III
[2010] Ryan Billows vs Midnight Cowboy - ENDGAME / Gauntlet Hell - FOR QUEEN & COUNTRY

RIVALRY OF THE YEAR
[2002] SilverHAWK vs Osyrus
[2003] Alias vs Jason Kain
[2004] Superstar Vince Jacobs vs Alias
[2005] Superstar Vince Jacobs vs Alias vs Khristain Keller
[2006] Andy Sharp vs Seymour Almasy
[2009] The Minutemen vs All-Star Championship Wrestling
[2010] Z vs ACW

SHOW OF THE YEAR
[2002] ENDGAME 2002
[2003] KING OF AGES 2003
[2004] RELENTLESS 2004
[2005] ENDGAME 2005
[2006] LEGENDS II
[2009] COURAGE - APRIL 2nd - FIGHT NIGHT
[2010] ENDGAME 2010